top of page
Search

nida manzoor & the imperfect muslimah

Writer: yharazayyd
yharazayyd
May 22, 2023
8 min read



A book called The Ideal Muslimah had a special place on our home. It sat, perched between a book of hadiths and a book of duas, on the mantel above our fireplace. I read it every so often, trying my best to be not just the perfect Muslim but the perfect Muslim woman. But even in my off and on stages of wanting to attain impossible perfection, I couldn’t follow everything laid out in the book, mainly because there was so much to remember and partly because there were many things that, fortunately, didn’t apply to me.


There were passages on following authority and being obedient, passages about exercise and staying fit, passages about the importance of choosing the right partner and marrying. It was that last chapter that filled me with the most dread. I had been told throughout my entire childhood that marriage was something I should want, that marriage was the end goal. I still remember the first time someone asked my then stepfather about possibly marrying me. We had gone to the masjid for Jummah prayer and after it was over, we all piled into the car. When my stepfather got into the driver’s seat, he turned to me and said, “That brother is interested in marrying you.” I looked out the back window of the car and saw a man who – and I say this with the utmost generosity – had to have been in his late 50s. I was ten.


I didn’t know it then but I was very lucky to have had a mother and a stepfather who didn’t stand for that kind of shit. My stepdad laughed it off because the idea was so ridiculous to him while my mom quietly seethed in the passenger seat. She later told me that he – the man asking for my hand – “should be ashamed with his geriatric ass.” Even though his incident didn’t lead anywhere, I was still so anxious, even more so because of it.


I was just a kid. I wanted to spend my days skateboarding, I wanted to dye my hair, I wanted to buy a guitar and start a punk band (fun fact: the first song I ever wrote was called “Valentine Sleeps.” Yes, it is as terrible as it sounds). The real reason I sat down every so often to read The Ideal Muslimah was because I had this debilitating fear that I didn’t have it in me to be that ideal. The truth was behaving like that highly esteemed ideal seemed like a terrible fate. It seemed like I had to go against everything I wanted for myself in order to fulfill that role. I was already shy and soft-spoken but the idea that I had to be quiet and subservient scared me. Just because I didn’t like talking often didn’t mean I didn’t want to stand up for myself, didn’t mean I didn’t want to advocate for myself or that I wanted to bite my tongue and nod when I was insulted or demeaned or talked down to. I struggled with these two identities – the ideal Muslimah and the authentic Me – for as long as I can remember.


When I joined a talent agency and started going to auditions at eleven years old, my mom told me not to mention it to anyone at the masjid. When I eventually got an acoustic guitar during my sophomore year of high school and taught myself “Smoke on the Water” as is required in the novice guitar player handbook, I couldn’t mention my progress to any friends I had at the masjid or to anyone else for that matter. For that reason, I started to feel stifled and like something wasn’t quite right with me. I knew who I really was but I also knew who I had to be and trying to come to terms with that felt impossible. In short, Hannah Montana, while very different in tone, was an important show for me at the time because I didn’t know any other tweens having two personas, two lives and feeling the pressure to keep secrets all the time.

As I got older, I just embraced more of who I am and let go of living up to any unattainable ideal. Muslim, me, mixed all together and you get a very flawed human being. I thought I had made peace with my identity, that I had it all figured out but then Nida Manzoor came in and set everything on fire.


I sat with my mouth hanging open, eyes wide and heart beaming the first time I saw the trailer for Nida Manzoor’s television show We Are Lady Parts. I couldn’t believe what I was seeing was real. Can it be? Muslim women…in a punk band…singing songs about ignorant people asking what’s under their hijabs? Holy shit.


We Are Lady Parts, despite only having one season, has become one of my favorite shows of all time. I carry it in high esteem because it’s a good time, it’s a wild ride and because, aside from Hannah Montana, I never knew I could see my identity crisis so clearly depicted on screen. I mean, the main character literally hides her music collection and her guitar in her closet. So, what’s the show about?


Amina is a 26-year-old, unmarried, highly successful woman who teaches guitar to the youths in her spare time. Despite her high success and her contributions to her community, her unmarried status is a real point of contention for her. Especially after her best friend Noor gets engaged. Although Amina wants to get married, she struggles to find the right potential partner. Either her potential mate is just not a love connection or he and his family run for the hills when they find out she plays guitar (“Music is haram,” one of her potential suitors says in a scene that belongs in the Louvre of comedy). But then she sees him, Ahsan, on the street. He’s gorgeous, fit, cool and he’s passing out flyers for punk band auditions. When Amina takes one of the flyers and goes to the address in the hopes of finding Ahsan and eventually marrying him, she’s instead met with the three members and manager of the noise punk band We Are Lady Parts.


Momtaz, the manager, is a goth niqabi with a vape addiction and, frankly, balls of steel. Saira, the guitarist, is a tattoo-covered butcher who doesn’t wear the hijab but who also prays consistently. She’s been ostracized by her family for her life decisions and she’s amazing. Bisma, the bassist, is a hilarious, bold artist with her own series of graphic novels all about periods. Lastly, Ayesha, the drummer, is a badass, fiercely loyal free spirit who never hesitates to speak her mind. Initially, when Amina meets these woman, she wants nothing to do with the band mainly because she, too, is trying to be the ideal Muslimah, hiding her guitar away in the dark and waiting to get married so she can be considered to be fully righteous and “complete.” But when Amina plays guitar, she always fades away into this blissful haven of freedom and happiness. And when she plays guitar with the band, she feels that way all the time.


In a pivotal episode of We Are Lady Parts, the band has a piece written about them by this insidious journalist and she twists their words to make it seem as if the band has a gripe with Islam, that they’re rebelling against being Muslim. Naturally, they all take offense to this. As early as episode one, there’s a scene of the band, immediately after completing band practice, doing one of their daily prayers. They’re all believers even if other believers don’t view them as such. They all have different things that would make the more self-righteous in their community view them as less than. Amina with her guitar playing, Saira with not wearing hijab, Bisma with drawing graphic novels and Ayesha with her identity as a queer Muslim woman.


Eventually, Amina reaches a point where she no longer feels marriage is going to complete her. She and Ahsan have a truly adorable flirtation going but it never becomes more than that and that is enough. She’s happy where she is, she doesn’t need marriage to complete her, she doesn’t need to be this perfect Muslim to be a Muslim. That theme is prevalent across all the characters in We Are Lady Parts, across all characters in Nida Manzoor’s work thus far – that one doesn’t need to be a perfect Muslim to be a Muslim.


Earlier this year saw the world premiere of Nida Manzoor's debut feature film Polite Society. Equal parts action comedy and coming-of-age story, the movie follows Ria, a teenage stunt performer in the making. Ria is passionate about fighting. She never misses a karate class, keeps a YouTube channel dedicated to the art and even practices her stunts in her free time with her beloved sister Lena. Ria's relationship with Lena is really the heart of this story. It's an action adventure, it's a side splitting comedy but it's also a love story about the strength of love between two sisters who just want the best for themselves and for each other.


Lena, an art school dropout, is in a deep depression when this story begins. Having just abandoned her passion in fear that she isn't good enough to fulfill her dream, she spends her days at home, mostly wasting away in her bedroom while she reflects on the past and tries to figure out what lies ahead for the future. The only person who manages to pull her out of her sorrows is Ria who constantly encourages Lena about her art. When Lena and Ria are dragged to an Eid Soiree by their parents, Lena meets the handsome and successful Salim and the two quickly fall head over heels for each other.


Although Ria's parents are teeming with joy, happy that Lena is no longer depressed and relieved that her life has moved forward, Ria is absolutely abhorred and disgusted. She sees Salim as a threat, encroaching on the comfortable world that Ria and Lena have created. To her, Salim is also a distraction that's taking Lena away from her art and Ria's worst fears soon become a reality when she comes home to find her sister engaged and her art destroyed. For Ria, Lena letting go of her dream isn't just about wanting her sister to get what she really wants in life. For Ria, Lena letting go of her dream means that one day Ria will have no choice but to give up on hers.


Even though these fears Ria has are soon worsened by newfound knowledge about what Salim and his mother Raheela are really getting up to, the idea of having to sacrifice one's dream for someone else's is the main thread of this story. (Perhaps, one day I'll get into it in detail but as of now, despite the fact that this movie has come out over a month ago, I'm wary of spoilers). And it's not a mistake that most of the characters struggling with this fear of having to sacrifice their desires are woman. Whether it's Ria, Lena or Raheela, they're all afraid of putting their life on hold in order help someone else's life move forward. While this fear is relevant to everyone, woman or man, as an imperfect Muslim woman, I recognize this as one of the many things I struggled with.


One of the reasons I was so afraid of marriage and so afraid of not being able to fit the mould of an Ideal Muslimah was because I had my own hopes and aspirations that didn't reflect any of what was expected of me. And I feared so deeply the possibility of living for someone else and not for myself. Getting married would change that, trying to be perfect would change that and Nida Manzoor is one of the few directors out there creating stories that reflect that conflict so perfectly. It's a little bit more than just "I'm not throwing away my dream, Dad, I'm throwing away yours," an entire subgenera, I swear. It's not just about external forces but it's about an internal struggle, fighting with yourself on who you are and who you've been told you're supposed to be.


It's a struggle that Nida Manzoor, while creating stories that are fun, funny and daring, never fails to communicate. Her work has done nothing but impress me and I, a very imperfect Muslimah, simply have the utmost appreciation for her. That is all.



 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Thanks for submitting!

© 2035 by Odam Lviran. Powered and secured by Wix

  • Facebook
  • Flickr
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
bottom of page